Back to Home
Free Resource

Builder Comparison Guide

Choosing the right builder is critical to the success of your building project — whether it's a new home, a knockdown rebuild, or a duplex development. This guide walks you through the evaluation criteria that separate reliable, quality builders from the rest.

01

Licensing & Registration

Every builder must hold a valid licence for the type of work they are undertaking. Licensing requirements vary by state, so verify the builder's credentials through the relevant state building authority.

  • Verify the builder's licence number on your state's building authority website
  • Check the licence class covers the scope of your project (residential, commercial, multi-storey)
  • Confirm there are no disciplinary actions or restrictions on the licence
  • Ensure the builder has appropriate Home Building Compensation (HBC) cover
02

Insurance & Warranties

Adequate insurance protects you if something goes wrong during or after construction. Never engage a builder who cannot provide proof of current insurance.

  • Home Building Compensation (HBC) / Home Warranty Insurance — mandatory for residential work over a threshold
  • Public liability insurance — covers damage to third parties on site
  • Workers' compensation — required if the builder employs staff
  • Understand the statutory warranty period (typically 6 years for major defects, 2 years for minor)
03

Quotes & Pricing

A detailed, transparent quote is one of the strongest indicators of a professional builder. Be cautious of quotes that are significantly lower than others — they may exclude critical items that will be added as variations later.

  • Compare fixed-price versus cost-plus contracts
  • Ensure the quote includes a detailed scope of works and inclusions list
  • Check what's excluded: site costs, landscaping, driveways, window treatments, fittings
  • Understand provisional sums and prime cost items — these can blow out
  • Ask about variation processes and how changes are priced and approved
04

Timelines & Contracts

A clear, fair contract protects both parties and sets expectations for the build timeline. Use a standard industry contract (such as HIA or Master Builders) and have it reviewed by a solicitor before signing.

  • Use a standard industry contract (HIA, Master Builders, or state equivalent)
  • Ensure the build timeline and milestone payment schedule are clearly defined
  • Understand liquidated damages clauses for delays
  • Clarify the process for extensions of time (weather, material delays, variations)
05

Quality & References

Past performance is the best predictor of future results. Ask to see completed projects and speak directly with previous clients about their experience.

  • Request at least three recent references and contact each one
  • Visit completed projects to assess finish quality first-hand
  • Ask previous clients about communication, timeline adherence, and issue resolution
  • Check online reviews and the builder's reputation in the local community
06

Red Flags to Watch For

Certain warning signs indicate a builder may not be reliable. Trust your instincts — if something seems off, it probably is.

  • Pressure to sign quickly or pay large upfront deposits before contract
  • Reluctance to provide references or proof of insurance
  • Quotes significantly below others without a clear explanation
  • Vague or incomplete scope of works and inclusions
  • Poor communication during the quoting phase — it won't improve during the build

This Guide Is Just the Beginning

The information above is a brief, indicative overview to help you get started. Property decisions involve nuances that depend on your individual goals, finances, and circumstances. For proper, personalised guidance tailored to your situation, speak with a PPS Property Strategist.

Contact PPS for tailored advice

Educational & Informational Purposes Only

Financial figures shown are estimates based on user-entered information and assumptions. They are not financial advice and should not be relied upon as a guarantee of future performance. Actual results will vary.

Ready to Put This Into Action?

Book a free strategy session with a PPS Property Strategist to discuss how these insights apply to your specific situation and goals.

Book Free Strategy Session
Interactive Tool

Suburb Analysis

Get a quick property snapshot for any suburb across Australia. This is a high-level overview — for a deeper, personalised assessment aligned to your goals, our strategists go far further.

Covers all states and territories across Australia. Figures are indicative only.